Discuss If part P were abolished in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

A lot has to be said of the individuals carrying out the work who just have a "that'll do" attitude and who have never seen a regs book , apart from the one they "borrowed " for the 17th exam.
It's these individuals who are niceic, napit etc , registered as approved contractors who also tarnish the industry.
 
Totally agree with you ian, but we can't slate them for not having their own copy of the Big Yellow book, On site guide etc. Don't forget that's Friday nights beer money they'd have to spend :).
Anyway, wouldn't be much point in them buying the books. Don't think half the buggers can even read :D
 
I think the scams are a big problem. As has been pointed out on here many times before, farming out oversight of domestic electrical work to companies who make their money from the same people they are overseeing was an idiotic idea. But then that's what happens when government policy is in effect made by private companies (huh? You say? Hold on I'll explain...). Tarquin studied PPE at Oxford, he resided in the same college as daddy used to, who was bestest chums with Hugh Daddy-Oldmoney, now the Minister for x. Tarquin has finished at Oxford and needs something to do so daddy's chummy-whummy gives him a job as Special Adviser for x in the Department (he's clever chap don't you know, went to Oxford). Of course Tarquin is keen to make his mark, and won't let the fact he knows f**k all about anything in his policy areas stop him (after all the Minister doesn't know anything about anything either, and the minions - civil service fast streamers who also went to Oxford, or that other one - also know f**k all, I mean, they were hired because they're super super smart right? Not cause they've got any relevant subject knowledge or industry experience right?). So no one's going to embarrass Tarquin by showing up his lack of knowledge, and besides, daddy's other chum, who is the director at so and so big business has said it just so happens they are lending out experts for free to the government to give them advice. How jolly nice of them, I'll introduce them to the minions, thinks Tarquin. They can be on the focus group. Oh what's that? They're offering to give some help to the sector affected by my policy area, they'll even put up most of the money! Six months later, Tarquin's minion is raising concerns that, now he's gotten to know one or two others in the sector, that so and so big businesses motivation for doing this lovely thing to help Tarquin might not be pure as the driven snow. Tarquin dismisses this as poppycock (besides so and so big business produced a nice glossy report showing how well they're doing and how much everyone loves them) and is glad the minion is moving on to his next 6 month fast stream posting next week...
 
Last edited:
I think the scams are a big problem. As has been pointed out on here many times before, farming out oversight of domestic electrical work to companies who make their money from the same people they are overseeing was an idiotic idea. But then that's what happens when government policy is in effect made by private companies (huh? You say? Hold on I'll explain...). Tarquin studied PPE at Oxford, he resided in the same college as daddy used to, who was bestest chums with Hugh Daddy-Oldmoney, now the Minister for x. Tarquin has finished at Oxford and needs something to do so daddy's chummy-whummy gives him a job as Special Adviser for x in the Department (he's clever chap don't you know, went to Oxford). Of course Tarquin is keen to make his mark, and won't let the fact he knows f**k all about anything in his policy areas stop him (after all the Minister doesn't know anything about anything either, and the minions - civil service fast streamers who also went to Oxford, or that other one - also know f**k all, I mean, they were hired because they're super super smart right? Not cause they've got any relevant subject knowledge or industry experience right?). So no one's going to embarrass Tarquin by showing up his lack of knowledge, and besides, daddy's other chum, who is the director at so and so big business has said it just so happens they are lending out experts for free to the government to give them advice. How jolly nice of them, I'll introduce them to the minions, thinks Tarquin. They can be on the focus group. Oh what's that? They're offering to give some help to the sector affected by my policy area, they'll even put up most of the money! Six months later, Tarquin's minion is raising concerns that, now he's gotten to know one or two others in the sector, that so and so big businesses motivation for doing this lovely thing to help Tarquin might not be pure as the driven snow. Tarquin dismisses this as poppycock (besides so and so big business produced a nice glossy report showing how well they're doing and how much everyone loves them) and is glad the minion is moving on to his next 6 month fast stream posting next week...
All pretty much true to form.
 
If part p was abolished i'd still be landing on a job with no certs etc , The point being its a start to clean up the trade like gas safe did . At the end of the day if your not doing your job right then These are the consequences. You now have to show certs to your rep etc and show compliance. How easy it was before being so lazy must be a good thing & also eventually consumers will stear clear of the wanna bees Getting you more work no?
 
Last edited:
If part p was abolished i'd still be landing on a job with no certs etc , The point being its a start to clean up the trade like gas safe did . At the end of the day if your not doing your job right then These are the consequences. You now have to show certs to your rep etc and show compliance. How easy it was before being so lazy must be a good thing & also eventually consumers will stear clear of the wanna bees Getting you more work no?
How does gas safe work in priciple
 
To put it simply there are no recommends/best practice or 6 suits to sign up to which incredibly includes Corgi !. Its 1 way or the highway. With Electrics its all interpritation x 6 . Dont get me wrong ' If it stays non statutory then we would hav no Forum LOL. Me Gas Safe +20
 
To put it simply there are no recommends/best practice or 6 suits to sign up to which incredibly includes Corgi !. Its 1 way or the highway. With Electrics its all interpritation x 6 . Dont get me wrong ' If it stays non statutory then we would hav no Forum LOL. Me Gas Safe +20
so what happens for any building control eg we have part P but plumbers have another part of building regs to comply with.
 
I am one of the old sparks you speak of, completed a JIB apprenticeship over 30 years ago, did my 17th edition and 2391, have rewired more houses than I care to remember, but sadly have to call upon someone with virtually no experience to work on my own house because of what I consider to be nothing more than a loophole.
The need for regulation is unquestionable but as is so often the way it was a rushed and badly conceived idea that should have been scrapped years ago.
 

Reply to If part P were abolished in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Similar Threads

Hi Folks , Just looking for a bit of advice as I'm looking to get back on the tools so please bare with me if this is a bit long winded. I'm a...
Replies
1
Views
578
Hello all, First of all I apologise if this is in the wrong forum, I figured the general forum may be the best bet :) Thank you for taking...
Replies
3
Views
504
Hello, I am an enthusiast amateur undertaking wiring of two outbuilding under a building notice. I am soon to be subject to a first fix inspection...
Replies
5
Views
948
Experienced Electrician, C&G 236 Parts 1 & 2, AM 1 & 2 18th Edition Am 2. (JIB Gold Card) I've been out of the trade for some time, but did a...
Replies
2
Views
857
Hello. I have a quick question for registered sparks on here. Can/ will / do you certify notifiable work done by others? I guess I’d have to...
Replies
18
Views
2K

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Electrical Forum

Welcome to the Electrical Forum at ElectriciansForums.net. The friendliest electrical forum online. General electrical questions and answers can be found in the electrical forum.
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock