Discuss Rcd discrimination in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

Reaction score
376
Hi guys.
Called to very strange call out today, cannot get around why and what exactly is going on.
Heres the set up,
TT system with a rod at 51ohms.
100mA s type rcd upfront feeding 2 units. A switch fuse to a submain for the main house db and single 30mA rcd board feeding the rental part.
Basically the fault was discovered while the customer was trying to re heat his tea! Lol
Either microwave will trip the 100mA RCD..... all final circuits are 30mA protected and cant see how this is happening.
RCDs trip at the following when not in series.
100mA S - 70mA, > 2000 @ 1/2 and 356 @ x1
So all ok.
30mA - 26mA, > 2000 @1/2, 56@x1 and 8@x5.
So all ok.
Until they go in series....
Then both trip at 1/2 there rated current. And sometimes when testing the upfront rcd it will tril the 30 after it.
Im so confused, Maybe over thinking it.
Thanks in advance.
 
You need to IR test and possibly clamp with an Earth leakage meter the various parts/DBs.

It is more than likely cumulative leakage on the 100mA RCD, it could very well be very near it's tripping point so to speak in normal use, if you can break down the individual leakages then you will have a better chance of seeing what is happening.
 
How many rod positions , and are they electrically separated from each other ?
 
There could be some leakage on the circuits already without the additional appliance just taking the 100ma rcd over the limit ,was the ramp test carried out with all circuits live , You could try an earth leakage clamp meter with appliance connected and trace any leakage back
 
Series , hope not , possibility a fault on one of the boards especially if its tripping the 100ma insulation test i think
 
Hi guys.

And sometimes when testing the upfront rcd it will trip the 30 after it.

Thanks in advance.
I am slightly worried about this statement, as if you are testing the 100mA S type at the RCD then there is no combination of faults that can trip the 30mA RCD because the "fault" introduced by the tester is upstream of the 30mA RCD so it cannot trip it.
Therefore it seems that there is a wiring error in the sub main supply arrangements, which is odd because it is difficult to do.
The only thing I can think of is that a neutral supply from one board is shared with the other board, but this situation would have tripped things from the start, so what has changed?
 
Hi guys. Thanks for the responses. Back on site now. Just to clarify.
61008 100mA s type rcd upfront.
4293 30mA in db.
I have fully tested the installation and no faults. Lowest insulation of around 25Mohms. Most > 500Mohms. Leakage clamp is showing combined leakage ecceeding 70mA which is what the rcd is tripping at.
I have just discovered two more tails that are coming off the back of the tail blocks through the wall into a changeover switch. This then goes to swa across the yard to a generator. At the generator there are more tail blocks and branched off to another changeover switch fed from a seperate service head!!
Both changeover switches appear to be single pole (neutrals have continuity in all combinations). So im thinking this is where my neutral path is, obviously not returning through the 1st rcd.
Thanks for the advice guys, just going to disconnect the generator cables and see if it clears my fault.
 
Hi guys. Thanks for the responses. Back on site now. Just to clarify.
61008 100mA s type rcd upfront.
4293 30mA in db.
I have fully tested the installation and no faults. Lowest insulation of around 25Mohms. Most > 500Mohms. Leakage clamp is showing combined leakage ecceeding 70mA which is what the rcd is tripping at.
I have just discovered two more tails that are coming off the back of the tail blocks through the wall into a changeover switch. This then goes to swa across the yard to a generator. At the generator there are more tail blocks and branched off to another changeover switch fed from a seperate service head!!
Both changeover switches appear to be single pole (neutrals have continuity in all combinations). So im thinking this is where my neutral path is, obviously not returning through the 1st rcd.
Thanks for the advice guys, just going to disconnect the generator cables and see if it clears my fault.

So you've THREE sources of energy, combined, with no neutral isolation, and sharing one common point of TT??! (Not of your doing, I realise). Jeez, let's just tear up the regs and make it up as we go along. With any luck we'll only kill the cheap labour.......
 
It is a complete lash up!!! I have disconnected the generator supply and all is good with regards to tripping. Have noted all the problems and surprise surprise. She doesnt want to do anything about them. Get the impression they have an "electrician" (so called) that installed all of this junk and when a fault arose couldnt sort it. So they called me.
Thanks to all for the help.
 
It is a complete lash up!!! I have disconnected the generator supply and all is good with regards to tripping. Have noted all the problems and surprise surprise. She doesnt want to do anything about them. Get the impression they have an "electrician" (so called) that installed all of this junk and when a fault arose couldnt sort it. So they called me.
Thanks to all for the help.

Good luck rich
 

Reply to Rcd discrimination in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Electrical Forum

Welcome to the Electrical Forum at ElectriciansForums.net. The friendliest electrical forum online. General electrical questions and answers can be found in the electrical forum.
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock