AM2 pass or fail? Wrong sized cable

[Adam Watson]

Hello people, just finished my Am2 today and all went well, finished everything and didnt really have an issue with anything in regards to install, testing and fault finding. But... when we finished i asked the examiner what are some of the mistakes people make. And he said installing the wrong cable size. I know i put 1.5mm instead of 1.0mm for the 2 way intermediate lighting circuit and i feel like bashing my head against the wall... any idea if this will just get marked down as a minor? As its not unsafe. Thanks

 

[Joshua]

There's nothing wrong with using 1.5mm for lighting. Most jobs I'm on use 1.5 so I'd say you've passed.

 

[Adam Watson]

There's nothing wrong with using 1.5mm for lighting. Most jobs I'm on use 1.5 so I'd say you've passed.

I agree, I've only ever used 1.5mm. Just have to wait and find out now

 

[Strima]

What did the design say?

Regardless of what happens in the real world part of the assessment is your ability to follow a design. If you do not install what the designer has stated then you have failed to follow his design so have failed that part of the assessment.

 

[LankyWill]

You will be penalised for it, you have to follow the spec regardless. When i did my am2 they were very adamant about following the spec by word without deviations.

 

[buzzlightyear]

don't worry, I did my am2 .I put in 6mm for the lighting two way .
and I passed .

 

[Andy78]

I forgot to put the gland on my MI, it ended up as a pot rattling round in a 20mm hole. Still passed though. Although I did go to pains to point out that it was the invigilator's fault for waffling to me while I was making the end off.

 

[Adam Watson]

What did the design say?

Regardless of what happens in the real world part of the assessment is your ability to follow a design. If you do not install what the designer has stated then you have failed to follow his design so have failed that part of the assessment.

Sadly the design did say 1.0mm.

 

[Adam Watson]

You will be penalised for it, you have to follow the spec regardless. When i did my am2 they were very adamant about following the spec by word without deviations.

Yeah ano that's why I'm curious about it. They can pick you for not following correctly

 

[buzzlightyear]

Sadly the design did say 1.0mm.

o well. nobody's perfect.

 

[Dave OCD]

Adam, can you let them know that you used 1.5 rather than the specified 1mm and show you realised your mistake ? That might help unless they're total jobsworths- and it's a much better mistake to make than using an undersized cable.

 

[Adam Watson]

Adam, can you let them know that you used 1.5 rather than the specified 1mm and show you realised your mistake ? That might help unless they're total jobsworths- and it's a much better mistake to make than using an undersized cable.

It finished today so I'm now waiting for my results, and i agree. I am hoping i will get marked down as am sure your allowed so many minors. If i was to wire the ring final in 1.5mm instead of 2.5mm i would understand. It is what it is, I'll just resit if fail.

 

[Risteard]

I'd say you'll be docked a mark or whatever. You certainly won't fail without losing more marks!

 

[Adam Watson]

I'd say you'll be docked a mark or whatever. You certainly won't fail without losing more marks!

Hope so!

 

[DPG]

Keep us posted.

 

[MJPD29]

They are very fussy about following the set drawing but it shouldn't be a fail as realistically there is nothing wrong with it. Hope it goes well.

 

[gazdkw82]

Hi Adam,

Could you send me a pm please. I don't want to hijack your thread and the forum won't let me message you.

Thanks

 

[Adam Watson]

Hi Adam,

Could you send me a pm please. I don't want to hijack your thread and the forum won't let me message you.

Thanks

Just have mate.

 

[Adam Watson]

They are very fussy about following the set drawing but it shouldn't be a fail as realistically there is nothing wrong with it. Hope it goes well.

Thanks mate.