Discuss Phone line hit by lightning in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

Reaction score
165
Customer phoned on Friday looking for a few jobs done, he says his BT line has been struck by lightning twice this year wiping out phones and routers etc. Is there anything can be done to protect his gear other than maybe one of those surge protection extension thingys??
 
There should be lightning protection in the main phone jack already. Surge protection on the electrical installation won't make any difference to the outcome if the phone line gets struck by lightning.
 
UK Telephone Wiring

The first photo on that linked page shows the spark gap surge arrestor in the main socket. I'm sure you can purchase supplementary in-line protection from RS Components or Farnell but if the direct strike is very close to the customer's installation it would still be a lottery whether the protection is going to prevent failures.

Another option would be to investigate optical isolation for the phone line but I think it might be expensive.
 
You might find that any supplementary protection other than that incorporated within some older NTE's (master Socket) may interfere with ADSL Broadband. However replacing the master is up to BT in cases of lightning strike and you can use a gas-discharge tube type protector before the router without a significant speed or signal quality loss - we used to routinely fit them. Farnells is the place to buy. Usually though, if even a near strike catches a phone line, the router is the cheapest thing they will need to replace. Marvo is right - that's a gas discharge tube and they are effective - but absent from modern NTE.
 
BT are going to look next week. I was up today and it had blown the master off the wall, but the armoured bt cable looked fine. What size of GDT would you fit and where?
 
ADSL Broadband Surge Protector: Amazon.co.uk: Electronics seem similar to the ones we used to use, and for the price I think they are worth a go. Trouble with lightning is its big in volts, and sometimes, even a copper lightning band wont cope!

We tend to use these CITEL surge protectors, protection against transient overvoltages where we install multiline systems. One thing to remember though - you can spend a fortune but lightning will still be lightning...lotsa volts and not a clue where to put it. Like kitchen fitters.
 
What size of GDT would you fit and where?
A discussion requires numbers. A surge may even be hundreds of thousands of joules. A protector that only claims to absorb hundreds of joules does what? Protection is always about where hundreds of thousands of joules are absorbed.

Will a 2 cm part inside a protector stop what 3 kilometers of sky could not? Of course not. Will that part somehow absorb hundreds of thousands of joules? Of course not. Those other protectors are only for a completely different transient that also does not harm modems and routers. Modems and routers already contain superior protection.

A surge that actually does damage must be absorbed by earth. Just like a lightning rod. Does the rod do protection? Of course not. The rod is effective (for structure protection) because it connects a surge harmlessly to earth. A protector is effective (for appliances) because it connects a surge harmlessly to earth.

Master sockets once contained these well proven solution. No longer because surges are so rare in the UK. Many are willing to just replaced damaged parts. And believe hearsay that nothing can protection from such events.

BT's switching computer is threatened by about 100 surges with each storm. How often is your town without phone and DSL service for four days? Never? Because BT installs this earthed protector on every wired BEFORE it enters the building. You need same on the master socket.

Classic examples are on page 10 of:
http://bourns.com/data/global/pdfs/bourns_osp_product_guide.pdf
Unfortunately even it is useless if not properly earthed. And best installed as far as possible from electronics (ie in the master socket). Unfortunately, rules say only BT can install it.

Protection is never provided by a protector. Either a protector connects low impedance (ie 'less than 3 meters, no sharp wire bends, etc) to single point earth ground. Or that protector only protects from another type surge that typically causes no damage. This rule applies to every incoming wire - not just telephone / DSL. Every wire must connect to earth either directly or via a protector before entering the structure.

These concepts have been proven by over 100 years of science and experience. And is why BT's $multi-quid switches remain unharmed with every storm.
 
Which I think, is longhand for "One thing to remember though - you can spend a fortune but lightning will still be lightning...lotsa volts and not a clue where to put it. Like kitchen fitters."
 
Which I think, is longhand for "One thing to remember though - you can spend a fortune but lightning will still be lightning...
Spend about ÂŁ1 per protected appliance for a superior 'whole house' solution. Or spend tens times more money for other devices (ie ADSL Broadband Surge Protector: Amazon.co.uk: Electronics) that do not even claim to perform such protection. A less expensive solution diverts even direct lightning strikes to earth. Remains functional. And costs less. Because protection was always about earth ground.
 
'Diverts even direct lightning strikes to earth' - really??? Daz
 
'Diverts even direct lightning strikes to earth' - really???
Why does BT suffer maybe 100 surges per storm without damage? Either lightning is connected harmlessly to earth. Or it hunts for destructive paths to earth via appliances. You make that choice. Earthing lightning without protector failure was routine for over 100 years. Today, even better devices accomplish that.

A lightning rod connects lightning harmlessly to earth to avert structure damage. An effective protector connects lightning low impedance (ie 'less than 3 meters') to earth to avert appliance damage. If not earthed before entering, then lightning will hunt for destructive paths to earth via appliances. Protection is always about a path for hundreds of thousands of joules to get to earth. Harmlessly outside or destructively inside.
 
Yeah but your post gives the impression that the 'less expensive solution' costing less than tens of pounds can do this. A lightning rod system is not the less expensive solution. Daz
 
Yeah but your post gives the impression that the 'less expensive solution' costing less than tens of pounds can do this.
It says "ÂŁ1 per protected appliance". Nobody said anything about 'pounds per protected structure'.

How many appliances need protection? Dimmer switches, CFL bulbs, mobile chargers, furnace, timer switches, RCDs, door bell, night lights, TV, dishwasher, clocks, air conditioner, refrigerator, recharging torch, smoke detectors ... a typical house. A 'whole house' solution remains tens of times less expensive than plug-in solutions. Is well proven by science and experience.
 
I'm still confused by your posts. What is your solution for a typical house, and how much does it cost? Daz
 
I'm still confused by your posts. What is your solution for a typical house, and how much does it cost?
If any wire enters a building, that wire must first connect low impedance (ie 'less than 3 meters') to earth ground either directly (ie coax cable, satellite dish) or via a 'whole house' connector (phone, AC electric).

Critical is where hundreds of thousands of joules dissipate. Many want a magic box as if it will avert damage. It doesn't even claim to. The most important component of any protection system is the single point earth ground. And how wires inside every incoming utility cable connect to it. The price will be unique to each building. But it remains the least expensive and most effective solution.

Many do not need this well proven solution. Since damage throughout the world is maybe once per seven years. And so much less often in the UK. However some venues have seen damage or do not want the risk. Only solution implemented anywhere that damage cannot happen is about connecting the destructive anomaly low impedance (ie 'less than 3 meters') to single point earth ground. For each wire, either using a hardwire connection or using a 'whole house' protector.

Components for effective protection were listed earlier. Are provided by companies with better integrity including ABB, Siemens, Keison, AEL Group, and General Electric.
 
Sounds like a lot of waffle to me. How much to protect my house and what do I need? Daz
 

Reply to Phone line hit by lightning in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Electrical Forum

Welcome to the Electrical Forum at ElectriciansForums.net. The friendliest electrical forum online. General electrical questions and answers can be found in the electrical forum.
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock