Replacing smoke alarms

[Steve T]

Hi

I need to replace two smoke alarms in my house, one is in the hallway and the other on the upstairs landing. They are interlinked, and 240 volt powered.

Which type of smoke alarm would be best for these places, and do you have any suggestions of any particular brand of smoke alarm to use? (They don't need to have the terminals on them as there is a back box in the ceiling)
Thanks for any advice

 

[Octopus]

What make do you have now ?

 

[Steve T]

What make do you have now ?

They are both 'kidde fyrnetics' and they are both being replaced

 

[gutterball]

Aico.

 

[Octopus]

Aico

2 x optical

Don't be fobbed off with the cheaper ionisation units.....

 

[ruston]

Again , Aico.

 

[Steve T]

Just had a look at aico, seems like they are a reasonable price too, so will go for two of these: Mains 146 Optical Smoke Alarm + Alkaline Battery - https://www.tlc-direct.co.uk/Products/EI146RC.html

Thanks for the advice

 

[Lee42]

Go for the ones which have the 10 year lithium batteries,(ei161). you will be replacing the 9v batteries when they run out in the other units, and cursing at them when they are bleeping in the middle of the night

 

[Lee42]

I woul

Just had a look at aico, seems like they are a reasonable price too, so will go for two of these: Mains 146 Optical Smoke Alarm + Alkaline Battery - https://www.tlc-direct.co.uk/Products/EI146RC.html

Thanks for the advice

I would recommend going for the lithium version.
Can fit and not worry about batteries running out

 

[gutterball]

I would fit the lithium ones. They are not much more and it saves you having to remember to change the batteries.

 

[Steve T]

Ok, I think I'll get two of these then: Ei Evolution Optical Smoke Alarm + Lithium Back Up Ei166E - https://www.tlc-direct.co.uk/Products/EI166E.html

 

[Risteard]

Aico

2 x optical

Don't be fobbed off with the cheaper ionisation units.....

There are certain (rare) occasions where ionisation detectors should be fitted instead of optical detectors. For a hall and landing I would agree with optical though.

I must say I'm surprised that England still allows a pathetic LD3 system in domestic new builds.

 

[Sparky_marky2]

Can't go wrong with Lithium for the small extra cost.

 

[tazz]

There are certain (rare) occasions where ionisation detectors should be fitted instead of optical detectors. For a hall and landing I would agree with optical though.

I must say I'm surprised that England still allows a pathetic LD3 system in domestic new builds.

Why you are protection the escape routes in a dwelling, same as and L4 in commercial situation. Minimum requirement.

 

[Risteard]

Why you are protection the escape routes in a dwelling, same as and L4 in commercial situation. Minimum requirement.

Things have moved on elsewhere though. In all of Ireland (both north and south), and I believe Scotland, the requirement is for an LD2 system. In fact in the south with IS 3218 the requirement is expected to exceed the LD2 system once the Building Regulations catch up.

 

[tazz]

Apart from an added heat detector in the kitchen or high risk area, only the escape routes are still covered under LD2

 

[Risteard]

Apart from an added heat detector in the kitchen or high risk area, only the escape routes are still covered under LD2

It also means a smoke detector in the living room.

As I said, IS 3218 goes much further.

 

[tazz]

If there is a risk in living room say open fire then yes....but this is where most of built up England do not have such risks. So the standards are just the same under part 6 but not required. Classic would be solar panels and control in loft areas, now this would class as a risk for detection within roof spaces, something missed alot in England

 

[ashg285]

Hi

I need to replace two smoke alarms in my house, one is in the hallway and the other on the upstairs landing. They are interlinked, and 240 volt powered.

Which type of smoke alarm would be best for these places, and do you have any suggestions of any particular brand of smoke alarm to use? (They don't need to have the terminals on them as there is a back box in the ceiling)
Thanks for any advice

Aico lithium