Discuss Which panels and inverter..... in the Solar PV Forum | Solar Panels Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

P

Pavlaba

Hi, been looking at a 4kw Pv install and got it down to two possible inverters and two possible panel types.
Ive found company that I'm happy with to do the work and have prices from them.
what would you go for taking in account price, return etc?

So the panels are either solarworld or Hyundai. Both will be the all black type.
inverter will be either power one aurora or sma sunny boy.

which would be the best combination.

looking price wise at £400 difference between the inverters and £300 difference between panels.

also are the immersun type devices worth it? Looking at £400 extra to add one. Fitted price at time of install?

cheers for your help.
 
At 4kWp, yes an immersun type device is worth it so long as you have an immersion heater in your hot water teank. - There are examples of payback even for those on mains gas elsewhere on this forum.

Which inverter with which panels :) ?
 
At 4kWp, yes an immersun type device is worth it so long as you have an immersion heater in your hot water teank. - There are examples of payback even for those on mains gas elsewhere on this forum.

Which inverter with which panels :) ?

Thanks for your reply. The panel and inverter is any combination, so could have the Hyundai panels with either the power one or SMA inverter for £400 more. Similarly I could have the solarworld panels for £300 more than the Hyundai's with power one or for another £400 the SMA inverter, meaning £700 between the cheapest and most expensive options.
 
Difficult to offer advice without seeing the job. I'd probably go for the Power One and the cheaper panels if there's no shading involved.

Didn't the installer give you some information on which to base a judgment? They are supposed to be the experts in solar so why don't they decide what's best in your situation or are they passing the buck?
 
South east facing, 45degree pitch on roof. No shading at all. I have some info on the different options but they are kinda passing the buck. They said that they are all good products, and that they have done a very good price on the solarworld panels, so probably would recommend that with the power one, as the solarworlds are worth a lot more than £300 extra for a 16 panel 4kw array
 
I had better first register an interest as Logical Energy has been a wholesale seller of SolarWorld since 2010. We have also sold a range of european and chinese product. I have to say that nothing I have seen so far has come close to the build standard of the SolarWorld panel. The extrruded and jointed ally frame, the use of 4mm low iron float glass, a backing sheet that exceeds the minimum standard on UV exposure by a factor of 40 are just some of the areas that make the SolarWorld panel such a compelling product. It was always too expensive for most jobs. Now however, the price is more realistic and I would say the extra £300 is worth it. But there again many others would say...''you would say that!'
 
If you have no shading then we'd usually spec for a Steca Grid 3600 inverter. German manufactured and 7 year warranty as standard and has a euro efficiency of 98.3% so 2-3% higher than any other inverter on the market
 
I would go for the power one invert, we install a lot of these and they are as good a quality as the sunnyboys. Don't think the panels will make a great deal of difference over the 20 years
 
Can't streas enough if the panels are all on the same roof and there is no shading Steca grid inverters are the way to go. 2-3% better efficiency for 20+ years will make a lot of difference.
 
Panel performance and yield will make a big difference over the 20 years. An extra 100kWh a year could mean over £1,000 of extra income in the 20 years. The Photon tests in Germany show that some panels yield more power per labelled Wp than others. Another issue to look at is performance warranties. A panel that falls to 80% after 15 years could be producing considerably less than a panel that has a linear performance warranty. A panel with 0.7%pa performance degression will still be at 90% at the 15 year mark. A 4kWp system producing at 900kwh per kWp now would be producing 2,880kwh if the panels drop to 80% performance but only to 3,240 kWh if the performance had dropped to 90%. It can add up to a lot of money. Spend a bit more money now on good panels and good inverter it will be worth it in the long run.
 
I'm not sure where you are getting 80% after 15 years from as all panel manufacturers have performance at 80% after 25 years so 0.8% reduction per year. A panel manufacturer (say solar world) who have 0.7% guarantee per year would mean a system producing 3600 kWh in year one would produce 3,040 kWh after 25 years at 0.7% reduction and about 2940 kWh at 0.8% reduction after 20 years.

You'll make about 100 kWh more per year using a Steca Grid inverter. Stuff like high temperature and low light performance of panels are just if not more important than 25 year performance warranty guarantees
 
A typical panel like the Hyundai has a guarantee that states 10 years for 90 % of warranted min. power, 25 years for 80 % of warranted min. power. So for the first 10 years output should not drop below 10% of rated output and then for the next 15 years it should not drop below 80%. A total of 25 years of performance guarantee. If you draw a graph of the two guarantees ,% against time, the area above the stepped guarantee is the exta guaranteed performance you will get. I took 15 years as a median point to illustrate the performance difference. A number of manufacturers are now offering a linear guarantee whilst others are not. You can draw your own conclusions.

You are right about the inverter. Correct inverter choice is important and I don't just mean matching the electrical performance. Lifetime performance and efficiency are key. Some of the lower cost inverters are lower cost because they use lower grade components. Components that are operating on the threshold ratings will not last as long as a component that is comfortably in spec. Design and build quality is another. Where compromises and short cuts have been made in design they will show themselvesover time, I am a big fan of the Steca inverter unfortunately they seem not have caught on in the same way as SMA Fronius and PowerOne
 
The big problem with output performace gaurantees, is that 99 times out of 100 they are not worth the paper they are written on. (linear or stepped)

About the only people that can afford to properly monitor and test the actual outputs as they wil have to be done under STC are the megawatt ground installations, so to Mr and Mrs Jo Bloggs, they make good sales spiel, and impossible to check....

Look at the terms too, if you aren't one of the megawatt sites, I doubt you'll ever be able to claim....
 
Once installed it becomes very hard to monitor individual panel performance (although fitting micro inverters is a solution). There are so many other factors that will impact performance. I think that over the next few years a number of issues will become important. Already in the States there are an increasing number of panels suffering from delamination. UV endurance is essential for the continued performance of the panel. IEC standard only requires 15kWh per square metre, however the average UV radiation for central europe is 50 kWh per square metre. I dare say there will be panels suffering from UV degredation only after a few years.
Quality costs and lower cost modules are unlikely to have had peel tests, electroluminescence hotspot tests, enhanced mechanical and inclined plane load tests even hemispheric lighting tests. These are all to all to improve life performance. After all these panels are going to be on the roof pumping out power for the next 25 years and hopefully a lot longer. That is why it is worth paying a few extra pence per watt now.

I agree most guarantees are not worth the paper they are written on, but some are. The main purpose of these guarantees is to give peace of mind, but that can only be given if there is substance to back the claims. A printed pdf datasheet and a copy of third party insurance is not enough. A detailed description of the quality assurance procedures and performance criteria is. Guarantees should just form part of a complete package of information. The consumer is looking to the installer as the one that knows these things and will help them come to the right decision. Unfortunately in my experience not all installers are like that. Maybe it because in many cases they are asking the wrong person
 
AAgh, the preserve of the shiny suit brigade :)
Sorry @logical Joe Bloggs public isn't going to do that kind of reaearch, and I'm not usre I'd believe the maunfacturers claims anyway. There again some people tell me I'm a cyinic when it comes to those claims.
Only an independant set of verified tests in some kind of published comparison database (e.g. photon report) will carry any provenance
 
Worcester I know what you mean. Having been a procurement specialist in the electronics industry for many years I have had my fill of the shiny suits and I think I can cut through most of the BS. I am not surprised at your cynicism, some of the things I have heard claim does beggar belief at times and cynicism is a form of protection but it can blind you to something that is of value. I have already mentioned the Photon tests and it is a good place to start. If a company is making performance claims their product should be in or near the top 10 consistently year after year. Some panels have a blinding year and then fall back down the performance list. Some panels will be in their 5th year of the run and some will be in their first. The Photon test gives some great information but it is open to interpretation.
Of course Joe Bloggs public is not going to do the proper research even if they think they do. There is so much misinformation and un-informed opinion in amongst all the good stuff. Even the most switched on customer would struggle. That is why the installer (not the shiny suit) is there to give value information to help the customer. They are the ones with hands on experience. They are the ones that should be doing the research. They are the ones that should be looking at the build quality of the panel, the quality of junction box, the quality of materials used. It is a matter of using ones eyes and judgement and asking the right questions of the manufacturer. If you can go on a factory visit go and see for yourself and understand what some manufacturers are doing and why. There are some large scale manufacturers who would not stand up to this scrutiny.
I feel for the OP as they were asking for a little guidance as to panel and inverter choice, they may or may not have been given advice by the installer they may have just been looking for re assurance. My point was go for quality every time. Now it is down to me to supply the installers with the tools that can help prove the quality of the panel. Something that will get through to the most battle hardened and industry bashed cynics.
 
Hi Pavlaba, check out this website

Hi Pavlaba,
I recommend to have a look at our website, Midsummer Energy - TRADE AREA and try to design your own system in our own program, http://easy-pv.co.uk/ , it's very easy to do it, you just need to follow a few steps:

1-. Draw your roof.
2-. Select and lay out the panels on the room.
3-. The frame will be designed automatically in the next step.
4-. Then you just have to add the Ac and DC isolators, the number of them are already calculated by the program.
5-. Select your control unit (Landis recommended)
6-. And monitoring unit if necessary.

Once you accept the design you'll get a quotation from Midsummer energy in a couple of days.

Hope to hear from you.

Best wishes.

Pablo.
Midsummer Energy.
 

Reply to Which panels and inverter..... in the Solar PV Forum | Solar Panels Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock