Discuss Wiring up garage lighting in the Electrical Wiring, Theories and Regulations area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

Thank you.
The simple truth is you are not going to stop people from doing DIY jobs on their own house, particularly if they are confident they understand what they are doing and work in other trades. Wiring the swa to the garage and wiring lights to a garage consumer unit couldnt have been more straightforward - 100% confident about the work I did. With the switch I was concerned that I might short the circuit if I got it wrong; without a ceiling rose I couldnt see a way of avoiding running the switched live to a neutral. This is why I asked the question to qualified trusted tradesmen rather than making a stupid mistake. Many thanks to everyone who replied and especially those who have helped.

You're welcome. Regarding my last..... What do you think about RCBO & RCD though?
 
Why a 20 amp MCB for a 16 amp socket?

It's to power a single phase table saw. When I had this set up in my old garage it kept tripping on start up. I changed the MCB to a type C with higher amps to account for the surge when it starts up.

100% confident about the work I did

So now you have a 16A socket wired to a 20A circuit..... Interesting....
 
Why have you got 2 x 30ma d
18th edition RCD back up back up. Discrimination is so 17th Edition you know lol
Why have you got 2 x 30ma devices in series Joe?
The rcbo in the house was just to isolate the circuit from the rest of the house. If the cable gets cut or damaged in the garden, I don't want anything else being affected in the house. I could have fitted another rcd + MCB instead but there wasn't room on the board. The RCD in the garage is for the garage circuits. I didn't see the need to add another main switch in the garage. Is that against regulations?
 
The rcbo in the house was just to isolate the circuit from the rest of the house. If the cable gets cut or damaged in the garden, I don't want anything else being affected in the house. I could have fitted another rcd + MCB instead but there wasn't room on the board. The RCD in the garage is for the garage circuits. I didn't see the need to add another main switch in the garage. Is that against regulations?

The point is that you have put two RCDs in series which does not comply. It raises the question of why you have provided RCD protection to the SWA distribution circuit which is normally unnecessary?
 
Purely to keep any moisture out. They are installed inside the garage but my sockets, switch and cu are all waterproof. OTT maybe but I'd rather play it safe

You say you’d rather play it safe but you won’t even pay for an electrician to check the work you have done? This is nonsense, if you wanted to play it safe you would employ a competent electrician.
Instead you have carried out the work yourself and created an installation which, based on what you have said, is non-compliant and dangerous.
 
You say you’d rather play it safe but you won’t even pay for an electrician to check the work you have done? This is nonsense, if you wanted to play it safe you would employ a competent electrician.
Instead you have carried out the work yourself and created an installation which, based on what you have said, is non-compliant and dangerous.
Non compliant; fine. I can change it. I can't see that's in any way dangerous though
 
Non compliant; fine. I can change it. I can't see that's in any way dangerous though

If you cannot see what is obviously dangerous then how can you consider yourself competent?
An OCPD rated higher than the connections on a single point radial is dangerous.
A lighting circuit with no functional switching and relying on the mcb for functional switching is incredibly poor design.
 
So now you have a 16A socket wired to a 20A circuit..... Interesting....
Ok. Again, this how it was set up previously. Can you explain to me then why it's ok to wire 13a sockets up to a 32a circuit?
 
Good, what will you change it to?
What is the EFLI of the distribution circuit?
Looks like I'll need to use another MCB on the distribution board then.
If you think I need a 16a type C for the 16a socket that's easily changed too. Can you explain why its ok to run 13a sockets through a 32a circuit then?
I obviously wouldn't have the first clue about how to calculate the efli of the distribution board and I don't need to. As I said Ill get a qualified electrician to check everything before powering on. Thank you though. You've given me some useful advice
 
Non compliant; fine. I can change it. I can't see that's in any way dangerous though
No, but if you want a third party to test and sign it off it needs to be compliant.
If you have a 16A socket fed from radial circuit you want the protective device to be no higher than 16A.
 
I didn't ask for advice. I asked if my wiring would work and if there was an easier way. You have advised me to pay for an electrician to do my donkey work though. Thanks for taking the time to reply but Ive explained that I've already done the work. You could save yourself the trouble next time.
Well that's that then.
 
Thanks for the advice Pete but if I need a 20mm hole drilling through the wall of MY house, a hole jigsawed through the ceiling of MY bathroom and a trench dug through MY garden, I'll be doing that myself thanks.
OK well that's me told then
 
Can you explain why its ok to run 13a sockets through a 32a circuit then?

because the 13A BS1363 plugs are fused.
 
As I said Ill get a qualified electrician to check everything before powering on.

I can't see this happening, as you didn't do it for the original install, as the electrician would have commented on the 20A breaker on a 16A socket. This is entirely up to you at the end of the day...
 
I think everyone is wasting their breath here. The OP has made it clear they will do what they want, and the forum has made it clear that they shouldn't be.
Neither side is likely to change their tack, one through ignorance and stubbornness, the other through an educated and experienced view and stubbornness.
Let's call it a draw.
 

Reply to Wiring up garage lighting in the Electrical Wiring, Theories and Regulations area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock