Multifunction Tester Comparison Chart

[Former Sponsor TM]

View attachment MFT Comparison.pdf

Hi Guys, I've attached a PDF to this post which compares the most popular models of multifunctional testers that we sell and have enquiries for.

Looking through some of the previous posts I hope that this may be of some use to those that intend to purchase a new tester, but aren't too sure what features one model may offer over another.

Please note I've only compared current models of tester, for example the three new 17XX series of Megger MFT, not the 15XX series. The PDF is meant to be a quick overview, if there's anything else that you need advice or help with that the comparison chart does not cover, please contact us on 0113 248 99 66.

We've also got a multifunction tester comparison tool on our website which may also aid your decision.

Thanks :smile5:

 

[Mattz]

Great timing. Just what I was looking for. Thanks

 

[davemoorenipper]

Am sorted at the moment but will upgrade in future.Tks

 

[rfears]

Thanks for that - I'm just starting in the business and this is very useful information.

 

[highspark]

In all honesty you can't get a more rounded tester than the 9083p. I had one but screen got smashed. I'm now on a fluke 1652B and I can't stress how much Iwould like my old tester back. Its the cheapest on the market but also the easiest to use!

 

[brman]

very useful, especially as I am one of those asking questions recently.

a few questions if I may:
What is a 15mA continuity test for? I am guessing to prevent RCD trip but wouldn't you use a no trip loop test for that?

Also, an X against insulation testing on the 1710 vs a "not 1000V" for the 9083p? The specs look the same to me (ie. 250&500V) so why the difference in the table?

btw. does the 9083p really not come with a calibration cert?

lastly, what I would love to see in the table is which auto start like the meggers do on continuity and loop.

Thanks,
Toby

 

[Guest123]

Thanks TM, I'll stick this one so it doesn't get lost.:icon4:

 

[Former Sponsor TM]

Hi brman,

If you can imagine that you are doing an end to end continuity test on a ring final circuit. For example, you would clip one of your test leads to the outgoing line conductor, and the other to the incoming line conductor to measure the continuity of that conductor. With a tester that has a 15mA continuity test, as soon as your second test lead touches the incoming line conductor, the continuity reading is instantly displayed. (Basically the autostart that you mentioned).

With a tester that doesn't have this facility and it's not generally a problem, you basically have to press a 'test' button to carry out the test. To be fair, this is a feature that a lot people will be used to anyway. 15mA is basically a safer current to test at than 200mA, hence why with a 15mA continuity test you do not have to press a test button.


Finally, regarding the insulation resistance functionality - the 9083p will test at 100V, 250V, 500V (marketed as a part P tester). It doesn't come with a calibration certificate, however it is supplied with a certificate of conformity stating that it has been tested to relevant standards.

The Megger MFT1710 will only test at 250V & 500V. Again, these are typical domestic insulation resistance test voltages and would not be suitable for testing installations designed to operate above 500V.

I hope this helps!

 

[brman]

Thanks Test-Meter, that is very helpful.

So are you saying the Megger 1710 does not have the continuity and loop test autostart that older 1502 and 1552 have? Of just that it is done at 200mA so not as safe?

Thanks
Toby

 

[Former Sponsor TM]

Hi Toby, the 17XX series of tester (1710, 1720, 1730) all feature the autostart continuity and loop functions that the Megger MFT1552 & MFT1553 featured.

 

[brman]

ok, thanks for confirming that.

Toby

 

[Former Sponsor TM]

No problem :smiley2:

 

[Former Sponsor TM]

Guys, we've also got a multifunction tester comparison tool on our website.

It's certainly a useful tool, some of you may have used it already when deciding what tester to purchase. It basically calculates a choice of testers based on what features you require, by simply clicking which feature you need, or are interested in.

As an ex-spark, I can really appreciate that you need to feel comfortable with your tester, and making the right choice of tester is imperitive. Hopefully the addition of these tools will help you overcome any doubts or queries.

Thanks!

 

[mountainman]

Totally confused now, I'm tempted by a Kewtech KT65 Ultimate kit.
Any thoughts please.
MM

 

[Spudnik]

Must admit, after the taxman giving me some money back this year, i am finally giving up the bricks and looking at the 1720.

 

[i=p/u]

and why not the 1730 for feew bucks more.. i must go on this comparrison chart.. its sounds the best

 

[Guest123]

Must admit, after the taxman giving me some money back this year, i am finally giving up the bricks and looking at the 1720.

It cant be true...........:svengo:

 

[DurhamSparky]

what tax man giving money away or jason giving up the bricks!!??

 

[Guest123]

what tax man giving money away or jason giving up the bricks!!??

J giving up the bricks of course...:indian_chief:

 

[Spudnik]

Yup, its time to put them on the antiques roadshow!:sifone:

Well, TBH i have two sets and one will end up on the bay, unless anyone else wants them.

Ill put them up for sale here first once i have my new one !

 

[rfears]

How does "put them up for sale here" work? I can't see an auction room here - do I need SpecSavers?

 

[Spudnik]

How does "put them up for sale here" work? I can't see an auction room here - do I need SpecSavers?

Forsale and Wanted forum.

 

[rfears]

Forsale and Wanted forum.

Specsavers ere I come:drunk:

 

[Spudnik]

Also, when i watched the demo video, the chap said that this can measure earth leakage with an accessory clamp?

Anyone confirm this?

Ta.

 

[i=p/u]

ive heard ones saying the extra clamp can measure earth leakage,

whats the difference between 1720 and 1730

 

[Former Sponsor TM]

Megger's MFT1730 will do the following that the MFT1720 will not:

Measure insulation resistance at 100V,
Test type 'B' RCD's (DC Current RCD's),
Measure earth resistance with the additional option of a ground resistance kit (this comes as standard with the MFT1730 Onsite version),
Rechargeable

The optional clamp will operate with all of the 17xx series of testers, and can measure earth leakage. It is also rated to 100A if you need to measure a higher current range.

I hope this helps :yes:

 

[Spudnik]

Well, i put mine to use today, and i have to say, it seems very slow when doing EFLI tests, on non trip and high current.

Anyone else have a Megger MFT that does this?

Is it just me?

Ta!

 

[Guest123]

Well, i put mine to use today, and i have to say, it seems very slow when doing EFLI tests, on non trip and high current.

Anyone else have a Megger MFT that does this?

Is it just me?

Ta!

I think MarkieSparkie has been in touch with Megger about this, this is his reply to another thread......


"In "No-trip" mode the Megger MFT electronics requires 3 wire L, N and E connections for power and reference so that the sophisticated method of noise cancellation that the Megger uses can resolve the impedance from the low level "No-trip" current pulses, even in an electrically noisy environment. It is because of this multiple current pulse and noise cancellation technique that the Megger gets unfair criticism from users of other MFTs (Fluke particularly) for it's apparently slow "No-trip" test, however, Megger users get the last laugh because they very rarely have their test inhibited by a noise error".

 

[QSGAZ]

Do you not sell fluke meters? Nice table tho thanks

 

[jase]

is the metrel mi 3125 b software mac compatible? ( i probably know the answer already)