Currently reading:
insert negative comments about Electrical Trainee here

Discuss insert negative comments about Electrical Trainee here in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

It would have been more interesting to post positive comments about Electrical Trainee, cause I can't think of any
Here's one then. There are guys on this forum who are products of the Electrical Trainee system (I'm not naming any names) The ones I'm talking about will know who they are. These guys have done the short course and realised exactly how limited they are at the end of it so they got off their backsides and went and got the knowledge that they needed to do what they needed to do. They stick rigidly to that and don't take any other work.
Some are very helpful posters and have gained a lot of respect from the guys like me who went down the apprenticeship route. Do I think the system is killing the trade? Yes I do.
Is it their fault? No
Hate the game, not the players guys.
 
I'm not saying apprenticeships are a thing of the past, but only that they are very hard to find these days and it will be a while until the number increases to decent rate to make these silly Electrical Trainee con courses obselete. I don't like the Electrical Trainee but as been mentioned you can't blame the people falling for it and handing over their hard earned, if there were any petitions to eliminate domestic installers I would personally sign it not out of spite for the people becoming Electrical Trainee but only to spite these riduculous companies selling false hope and creating some dangerous installers.

as for the old "I know Electrical Trainee better than apprenticeship served electricians" comment well that is just the only defensive lie a Electrical Trainee can utter when they can't defend against the common sense, fact of the matter is I know labourers which are more competant than domestic installers and I would swear to it, they have something that can't be bought experience...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Debate is fine, but please lets not have this thread turn into another bashing thread that we end up constantly editing and asking people to be civil. not that its gone that way but by its very design it has the potential to.

I sit on the fence personally, i agree with a lot of comments that the 5 week route is woefully inadequate, but if someone who has walked this road knows their limits and strives to develop and grow from their on, i dont see the problem, and the potentialy have the building blocks to shine. likewise being a apprentice trained spark is not indicative of ability or a attitude, i have met apprentice trained sparks that i wouldnt let put lights on a xmas tree!!.

i liken this to passing a motorcycle test, 5 days of intesive full time training, where you are trained to to ride to a sylabus, test on the 6th day........if your lucky is a "congratulations you have passed". Does this mean you can ride?.......not at all, the attitude and commitment you show in the coming years to your new craft/skill/hobby/obsession will determine the standard of rider that you will be forever!, me?.......well i worked like mad at it, gave it everything, to the point where i am now a race instructor at the Ron Haslam Race school, teaching people to race around SIlverstone (all done in my spare time as its only 13 days a year). Does this sound similar to a Electrical Trainee by any chance??

And if the Electrical Trainee sticks to minor works then they probably are near enough qualified and trained to be doing this kind of work.
 
I don't put all the blame on these training centre's, just maybe the best part of it. Anyone with a modicum of commonsense would know that your not going to be able to learn much in, from several days to a few weeks. A lot of this is down to the ''I Want It All Now'' culture that seems to reign these days.

To be honest, the UK is going to end up with very few fully trained Electrician in the future!! Most of the electrical industry will have been totally deskilled by the parasites you have let get strangle holds over you, and that give nothing in return!! We'll be importing qualified electricians from overseas then, similar to some of the worlds Third National Countries are doing now!!
 
Credit were credit is due.. I envy them. after 3 years training i dont earn 50k+. Advertising and salesman dont lie therefore if id gone down the short route then id be earning a hell of a lot more..

On another note. When i did my regs course i didnt learn anything whilst doing this about actual wiring. Yeah what zones to install cables ETC but not the basics like errm i dunno.. What colour is Live (You get the picture).. Yet NICEIC will allow you to become a DI after completing just this and legally work on a domestic property.


Training is everything in this game, However im sitting on the fence on this one.. I have worked with times served aprentice sparks who have been useless and on the hand worked with people who have got into the industry by just the short course method and have actually been decent sparks but not after 5 weeks....

However one thing i will be adimint on is its impossible to learn everything in 5 weeks in order to deem you a compitanct electrician
 
Hello, my name is Ben, and i.... am a five week wonder.

I have never tried to hide this fact, i joined this forum knowing full well that once i walked out of the door from my "training centre", i was in fact hugely under experienced and was terrified to start work. Since that day, i have sought help for almost every issue i have faced via this site, and have never faced any abuse from the guys who have helped me. Now, two years later, after grafting my arse off and being completely open to criticism and advice from all creeds and angles, i feel a pretty competent. I have achieved my 2/3 year apprenticeship by understanding that i will never have learnt everything and by asking for help.

I genuinely feel this forum has taught me more then i learnt at my 8 week course.

At the time i decided to take the course, i had no idea about other routes available, i had a son to feed, and bills to pay, and saw the option to the learn a trade that i naively felt was a good and stable option. I left with a level of understanding that gave me a platform to develop on. Sure, some Electrical Trainee's are looking for a quick sign off to go out and do poor work, but by generalising and saying we al a bunch of incompetent cowboys is the same sort of prejudice that would lose you a few teeth if you were stood in the wrong place and applied it a little differently.

there is a lot wrong with the short courses, no one is standing against that, but not everyone has had the oppurtunity to put up 3 years to learn the trade the "proper" way, i left university and was rejected from the police, again, due to severe prejudices within that organisation as i had all my limbs, faculties and was not a homosexual, i wasnt allowed in without waiting 5 years. Not so ideal when money is an unfortunate necessity of life. I opted to learn something applicable instead.

I now work as a plant manager and have worked hard to get here and do the job i do and continue to apply what knowledge i have to my job when i need to, and feel free to go over all my old posts, you will note i am far from the top of the tree and never afraid to ask.

The course gave me an opportunity to expand my career in different directions, the problem is you guys who have worked hard at college and earned your badges the traditional way, simply resent the short courses for undermining your hard work. Everyone can totally sympathise and understand that point of view. But like i have said so many times before on this subject, as it appears i am the only lad with the stones to step forward and confess to being a Electrical Trainee, that we are all in the same trade some way or another, why are attacking each other and constantly abusing each other.

We would do a whole lot better, looking out for each other, no matter what the back ground, and trying to put an end to the "sparks" who really are a cause for concern who show zero effort in bettering their knowledge and work practices and blatantly disregard the industry.

At the end of the day, and this is a poor comparison but bear with it, we don't hate on those who take intensive driving courses over 2-3 weeks and then are left to their own devices to drive on the roads, and lets be brutally honest, more people are killed on the roads each year then they are by electrical mishaps. They stil need some time to find their feet, but after time, who is to say they are any worse drivers than those who learnt over 8 months? Absolutely nothing. Ability is a mixture of effort + time + experience the road we all took to get there is a different story.

It's time to stop beating each other up, and get on with our own stuff. If i picked up a big re-wire next week, £8 large for the job, not one of you lads would turn me down if i offered you the work to help me out. That much i know for a fact.

My name is Ben. I am an (8) week wonder :)
 
Fair play to you there wade, good post...

Each week for 4 years at college only around 1 hour is practical, the rest is science's, maths, technologies etc all learning the under pinning knowledge. I think the problem isnt that it under minds our hard work but we know 4 years of under pinning knowledge is missing from the short course wonders, this wont be learnt by shadowing a spark or working as a sparkies mate for the few years after, by doing that you just pick practical knowledge/experience up, as an apprentice would the rest of the week he isnt at college.
 
I think it the scams that are killing it by allowing someone to join with only this limited training.

By all means do intensive c&g courses I don't see a massive problem with that. As long as your aware you have a piece of paper but no experience, and have not been sold the dream.

Then it would be down to employers to take people on as some with paperwork but no real practical skills. Then you would learn the trade.

What I do mind is the scams undermining the years of training the rest of us have done.

If the scams wouldn't take Electrical Trainee the it wouldn't give them electrician status instantly
 
5 week wonder or 3 or 8 ect ect, basically not electricians but domestic installers, they do very basic courses with no actual qualifications then they pay one of the part p scams a lump of money and then are allowed to install in homes in the uk, not many real electricians view these Electrical Trainee as nearly competant enough and it is a continuing dispute that will never be resolved
 

Reply to insert negative comments about Electrical Trainee here in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top