Fibreglass or Aluminium Stepladders?

[Electron]

I am about to invest in some new stepladders. I was thinking of getting Youngman fibreglass stepladders but have been told they are not as stable as aluminium. Also, are they really much safer for domestic electrical work? Aluminium stepladders have rubber insulated feet, which should give similar protection. What do you recommend?

 

[telectrix]

fibreglaass for best safety, ekectric wise. alli for less weight and cost. . your money, your choivce

 

[JOURNEYMAN]

I came off aluminium step ladders once and dislocated my shoulder. The only work injury I've ever had! Much prefer the fibreglass ones on a day to day basis as they're much more sturdy although they are heavier to carry about.

 

[chris gray]

Fibreglass all day, every day

 

[MDJ]

A lot of sites ban metal steps now, go down the fibre glass route, some sites even ban steps full stop.

 

[Octopus]

How high do you want to go up these steps ?

 

[Rpa07]

4 treads fibreglass will reach most things anything higher you’ll be looking for a different method. Fibreglass are sturdy.

 

[Deleted member 26818]

Do not rely on rubber feet that can wear out.

 

[telectrix]

How high do you want to go up these steps ?

maybe this high?

 

[Electron]

How high do you want to go up these steps ?

I was thinking of a 4 step: 52745401 | Stepladders & Stepstools | Youngman UK - https://www.youngmanaccess.com/uk/en/view/52745401
or maybe a six step:
52745601 | Stepladders & Stepstools | Youngman UK - https://www.youngmanaccess.com/uk/en/view/52745601
or both.

 

[Electron]

I was thinking of a 4 step: 52745401 | Stepladders & Stepstools | Youngman UK - https://www.youngmanaccess.com/uk/en/view/52745401
or maybe a six step:
52745601 | Stepladders & Stepstools | Youngman UK - https://www.youngmanaccess.com/uk/en/view/52745601
or both.

Just to get to ceiling height of most homes.

 

[telectrix]

5 tread with top platform. having holes for drivers and a couple of receptacles for bits like screws etc.

or get 1 of these. https://www.aladder.co.uk/item-werner_abru_fibreglass_stepladder_lock_in_job_caddy.htmlf

 

[Rpa07]

If it’s the only set you’ll have in a van then 5 or 6 tread. I’ve got a 3 tread + top ‘step’ that is not to be used as a step or a seat or even looked at in a funny way - I use it as a step, a seat and I pull some funny faces to keep it happy!
I also in the van have some fibre glass little giants 4 steps that extend, open up and do all sorts of funny things. Point is that I’ve got a little van NV200 Nissan and both these go in. If I need anything longer my ‘wooden doubles’ go on the roof rack.

 

[Octopus]

Just to get to ceiling height of most homes.

Try these :

Clow EN131 Professional Superglas Insulated Glassfibre Steps - https://www.ladders-direct.com/glassfibre-swingback-steps/219-clow-en131-professional-superglas-insulated-glassfibre-steps.html

I've had a 5 step version for about a decade ..............

 

[The Ghost]

I think if you do a risk assessment and method statement you will find you must have fibre glass non conductive ladder for so many scenarios. Personally I always use youngman fibre glass. 4 tread with platform 6 tread and 12 tread all fibre glass.

 

[Deleted member 26818]

Only real problem, is choosing a colour.

 

[Midwest]

Me I got some cheap 3 step ali ones from B&Q's. When they broke, I got some more. If its all domestic work, there's no manic site agent giving you grief, or the chance of marking Mrs Miggins Vienna marble floor tiles or her shag pile.

 

['mr2'gd4u]

5 tread with top platform. having holes for drivers and a couple of receptacles for bits like screws etc.

or get 1 of these. https://www.aladder.co.uk/item-werner_abru_fibreglass_stepladder_lock_in_job_caddy.htmlf

Oooo thanks Tel I might have to invest

 

[123]

Are you going to be storing them in the van or on the roof rack? If on the roof rack then Fibreglass steps are unlikely to last too long

 

[Gavin John Hyde]

I bought a fibreglass platform step ladder recently in homebase as they were labelled wrong, got them for £63 instead of £90.
They had put wrong barcodes on the shelf and also the ladders. some were priced correct, so pot luck which you picked up. I only noticed as I was in there solely for them. so when I went through the till and got charged £63 i was well happy. went back next day to check the shelves.

 

[MFS Electrical]

I am about to invest in some new stepladders. I was thinking of getting Youngman fibreglass stepladders but have been told they are not as stable as aluminium. Also, are they really much safer for domestic electrical work? Aluminium stepladders have rubber insulated feet, which should give similar protection. What do you recommend?

I’ve had fibreglass steps for years now and they are solid feel better on them than I have on any aluminium steps I’ve ever had but they are heavy as hell

 

[MFS Electrical]

I’ve had fibreglass steps for years now and they are solid feel better on them than I have on any aluminium steps I’ve ever had but they are heavy as hell

Mine have been on the roof rack for a few years as well the plastic cap on the top has discoloured and the bolts that hold the spreaders have a light rust but they are still pretty much ok I do wash them with the van every week though

 

[SparkyChick]

Worth mentioning as well... if you're not careful, it's much easier than you might expect to fracture the legs.

I was moving my steps a few feet when they were open, only to get one leg hooked on a door frame, I didn't realise and carried on going. Went off with a hell of a crack.

 

[telectrix]

Worth mentioning as well... if you're not careful, it's much easier than you might expect to fracture the legs.

I was moving my steps a few feet when they were open, only to get one leg hooked on a door frame, I didn't realise and carried on going. Went off with a hell of a crack.

so you now have a long john silver ladder?

 

[Deleted member 26818]

so you now have a long john silver ladder?

Nah, they’re yellow.

 

[MFS Electrical]

so you now have a long john silver ladder?

A peg leg?

 

[Nigel]

I think if you do a risk assessment and method statement you will find you must have fibre glass non conductive ladder for so many scenarios. Personally I always use youngman fibre glass. 4 tread with platform 6 tread and 12 tread all fibre glass.

Most risk assessments would assess out any risk of electric shock so having GRP steps is a non-starter.

 

[Nigel]

Makes me laugh when H&S insist on GRP steps to work on a high level metal CU.

 

[Deleted member 26818]

When I asked the H&S bloke at the factory where I worked if we could get glass fibre steps because the walls of the factory are metal and there’s a lot of water about.
His response was that we should stand the steps on a rubber mat.

 

[Nigel]

When I asked the H&S bloke at the factory where I worked if we could get glass fibre steps because the walls of the factory are metal and there’s a lot of water about.
His response was that we should stand the steps on a rubber mat.

Are the walls earthed?

 

[Deleted member 26818]

Are the walls earthed?

Possibly, not intentionally though.
They’re fridge panels fixed in place by a ‘C’ channel fixed to the floor and a top hat at the top supporting more fridge panels as a ceiling.

 

[sparkdog]

Glassfibre every time. Had one step collapse on customer's aluminium steps once, luckily without injury but it was a bit of a jolt. Always use my own steps now.

 

[chrisdungan]

Fibreglass be best
A lot of aluminium ones are rubbish as theyre too lightweight.
sturdier too

 

[rapparee]

If it’s the only set you’ll have in a van then 5 or 6 tread. I’ve got a 3 tread + top ‘step’ that is not to be used as a step or a seat or even looked at in a funny way - I use it as a step, a seat and I pull some funny faces to keep it happy!
I also in the van have some fibre glass little giants 4 steps that extend, open up and do all sorts of funny things. Point is that I’ve got a little van NV200 Nissan and both these go in. If I need anything longer my ‘wooden doubles’ go on the roof rack.

I had to get on the top step of a 10 thread set a few weeks ago, it was squeaky bum time to say the least

I sort of felt like this guy, fitting a led low bay

 

[Rpa07]

I had to get on the top step of a 10 thread set a few weeks ago, it was squeaky bum time to say the least

View attachment 45041

I sort of felt like this guy, fitting a led low bay

What a weird photo - why does he need to be on a step ladder when he’s in a stadium and everyone is looking down onto the ring - Oh, another unexplained phenomenon!

 

[sparkdog]

Looks like Super Spark to me.

 

[RonnyD]

The FiberGlass ladders feel more sturdy but weigh more so I always go with aluminum. I have found that ladders too tall for a given room are just a pain. I use a 6 foot ladder for the ceilings are 7.5 and a 10 foot where ceilings are 12 or more. Read more on differences of fiberglass and alluminium on this website

 

[7029 dave]

Thread resurrection, I only gave my wooden steps up a few years ago, heavy ole things but were great.
Got fibre now.