Discuss Potentially dangerous - should I report this to someone? in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Hi all,

Thanks for the welcomes and the advice.

In response to posts 4 & 6, it is definitely 2.5mm twin + earth.

It is not actually a new-build house, but the place had been completely renovated when I bought it and this circuit is in a fairly new extension.

There are two conductors in the MCB; It looks to me as though there used to be a ring around what used to be the kitchen, but when the extension has been done the ring has been broken into two radials, one going to the kitchen and the other to the utility room, and the two ends have not been connected back together to form the ring.

The overall floor area served by the circuit is slightly less than the 50m^2 stated in the regs. It seems to me that, with the 20A MCB in place, it is now safe. I plan to just leave it and see if the MCB starts tripping. If it does then I think I'll need to get a guy in to install a proper ring.
From what you've said here, and what you said in your original post, I think you need to get a competent electrician to inspect & test this circuit. Its possible that circuit in question was originally installed a as Ring circuit, and either has become faulty or was not correctly installed in the first place. It sounds as if the property has been renovated and in the process rewired.

You originally said the RCD was tripping, suggesting some kind of fault. The only way to investigate this is by testing, this will also clarify whether the circuit is an RFC or two radials in one MCB.
If the original installer cannot be located, then I would suggest using the services of a local electrician.
 
As above. For saying you are an electrical design engineer you don't seem to have much of a clue about this! How do you know it's not an RFC???
 
My money is on the fact its a ring but with spurs off spurs in the kitchen.

Matey - you need to get somebody competent with a MFT to confirm what exactly is going on...... before doing anything.
 
Ok, to post 21, yes initially the RCD was tripping, so I investigated this by going around the room, isolating each socket in turn and checking the live-earth resistance . I tracked the problem to a leaky junction box plastered into the wall (which I'm pretty sure was wrong as it should have been accessible for maintenance. That junction was just joining two lengths of cable so I replaced it with a new, single length of cable which I chased into the plasterboard. It was in carrying out this investigation that I noticed that when I isolated any one socket, a lot of the rest of the sockets would stop working, which is what started me wondering about the integrity of the ring.

So I spent my saturday mapping out all the socket connections - isolating absolutely everything and then testing the connections between each socket. I now have a complete drawing of the circuit in question, I know exactly what is connected to what, and I can assure that it is definitely two radials.

I did do the work myself but, being aware of my lack of experience of installation work, I checked all my plans with the electricians at work before I did anything, and got them to inspect everything I did, either in person or by photograph.
 
Ok, to post 21, yes initially the RCD was tripping, so I investigated this by going around the room, isolating each socket in turn and checking the live-earth resistance . I tracked the problem to a leaky junction box plastered into the wall (which I'm pretty sure was wrong as it should have been accessible for maintenance. That junction was just joining two lengths of cable so I replaced it with a new, single length of cable which I chased into the plasterboard. It was in carrying out this investigation that I noticed that when I isolated any one socket, a lot of the rest of the sockets would stop working, which is what started me wondering about the integrity of the ring.

So I spent my saturday mapping out all the socket connections - isolating absolutely everything and then testing the connections between each socket. I now have a complete drawing of the circuit in question, I know exactly what is connected to what, and I can assure that it is definitely two radials.

I did do the work myself but, being aware of my lack of experience of installation work, I checked all my plans with the electricians at work before I did anything, and got them to inspect everything I did, either in person or by photograph.

OP, please don't be offended, but I don't think you are qualified enough to be carrying out this work.

An RCD can also trip when there is a neutral to earth fault, and also when there is a fault on another circuit. When an RFC is installed, there are a series of test to be carried out to establish it has been correctly installed.

It would be unusual, but not uncommon, to find two radial circuits (for socket outlets) to be connected into one mcb. Hence the suggestion, that your circuit in question, was installed as a RFC, but somehow part of the ring has been disconnected, and you think you have two radials, especially as the original mcb was 32amp. I might be wrong. Unless the installer, forgot or missed part of the installation? Do you have two sockets with only one cable at each, but has continuity with the origin of the circuit (s)? This can be complicated by 'spurs' from your circuit. It is practice by some local councils, to turn a RFC into two radials, if a leg of the ring develops a fault. But the faulty cable would be isolated, and the two legs turned into two separate radials, in two separate mcb's.

When carrying out the installation work yourself, it should be properly tested before being bought into being. Having your plans checked by people at work, either in person or by photograph, will not facilitate this. Failure to carry out proper testing, sometimes ends with the predicament you find yourself in.

As you do not have the proper test equipment or sufficient experience, I would ask the 'electricians at work' to come and assist you, and rectify this problem.
 
I've seen quite a few 32A mcb's with 2 cables but they are not a ring.

Only somebody with a MFT and competence can really tell you!
 

Reply to Potentially dangerous - should I report this to someone? in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Similar Threads

Hi all. Sort of an interesting one. I had a call from a client to say she is getting a shock when using the shower. I told her not to use it and...
Replies
15
Views
1K
Hi, I am changing the electric shower in a bathroom refurbishment (my own) and just wanted to ask about the mcb rating. The existing shower was...
Replies
2
Views
737
I'm unsure if I should be an electrician or maybe another trade is better. I have basically completed my first year of a foundation in...
Replies
9
Views
697
Hi all, I am at odds on whether RCD protection is required on an SWA of 14 metres, clipped direct under flooring direct from CU to an exterior...
Replies
9
Views
751
Hi Everyone, I had a new consumer unit installed in December 2021, the electrician said that he had more testing to complete and would come back...
Replies
28
Views
3K

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Electrical Forum

Welcome to the Electrical Forum at ElectriciansForums.net. The friendliest electrical forum online. General electrical questions and answers can be found in the electrical forum.
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock