Discuss Buried SWA cable fault finding in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Out of curiosity though, how would an insulation resistance test work and would it help me locate the break? Or just confirm the damage exists?
It's exactly the same concept as a resistance test with a multi-meter, it just uses 500v dc not (probably) 9v. It can be thought of as a pressure test to confirm the condition of the cable and effectiveness of the insulation between the cores / armour. Any sparks worth their salt would do this test before considering re-energising the circuit. (you obviously aren't anywhere near that stage yet)
As Tel said if you were indeed measuring the actual fault with a multi-meter then it's a very low resistance fault indeed. An IR+continuity test device (most Megger BM devices do both) can measure resistance very accurately (to roughly hundredth of an ohm), much more accurately than most low-mid range multimeters where the good ones do +- 0.2 ohms.
So it would help confirm the cable's integrity and (best case) gain an idea where the issue is.
I do expect you to need a sparks at some point. It would be nice if you can find where the issue is though.
 
Could I confirm/ask some things please?

1. 3 core swa in one length?

2a. As far as you can tell with your multimeter the only continuity/contact is between one core and the steel wire armouring?

2b. There is continuity end-to-end on each core and for the SWA?

3. Please send me a photo of your multimeter.

4. Please draw me a plan of the garden, garage, CUs, cable route and tell me whether you can put your car in the garage - I'd need access to the car's 12V battery.

What is the first half of your post code?
 
Last edited:
Testing with a multimeter and/or an insulation tester cannot easily locate the damage. The plan of measuring resistance to the fault from each end doesn't always work because the end-end resistance of the cable is usually so much lower than that of the fault. It could be like trying to locate a pinhole in the channel tunnel by filling the tunnel full of water first from the English end and then from the French end, and comparing how fast the water flows in.

There are two standard methods to locate a fault. One does use the resistance of the conductor from each end to the fault, but in a balanced bridge configuration that is very sensitive and largely independent of the resistance at the fault. This type of Murray or Varley loop test can be done with a dedicated test instrument, or one can rig up a method using a reasonably high current source, some resistors and a multimeter. I think this is what Marconi is hinting at.

The other method is Time Domain Reflectometry, which injects a pulse into the cable and measures the time taken for it to be reflected by any features along its length (including the fault) that alter its impedance. Again it is normally done with a dedicated test instrument.
 
I’m learning a lot tonight. So it seems the principle of both Murray and Varley loop tests are that when the middle of a Wheatstone bridge measures zero volts you know the ratios of the two pairs of resistors are equal, so if three of the values are known the fourth can be calculated.

It would seem that whichever of the two tests are used one would need a voltage source, two known resistance values and a variable resistor to balance the bridge. I’m particularly fascinated how @marconi was going to improvise the variable resistor
 
I think this is the method that @marconi and @Lucien Nunes are discussing:
swa_fault_locate.jpg

Here the 3 conductors are joined at one end. One of the "good" conductors is used to feed a high-ish test current (say 5A from car battery & 60W lamp), the 2nd is used as a Kelvin connection to sense the voltage at the far end of the faulty 3rd conductor, and then the two voltages are measured:
  • V1 = drop from both R1 and R2 at I test
  • V2 = voltage across R1 due to the test seen by the fault to armour
You need enough current to get a measurable voltage, and you want it to be above the mV sort of point to avoid thermoelectric offsets.

Then the distance ratio = resistance ratio allows you to guess the R1 length as a fraction of total length (R1 + R2) from V2/V1
 
Last edited:
Well that’s certainly a bit easier than figuring this out…!
1631310638806.jpeg

I’d got as far as A and B being equal,
y adjusted so G is zero, meaning….
A/B=R/(X+y)
A/B is 1 so R=X+y or X=R-y
y is known.
That leaves half of a pair of simultaneous equations and I gave up and opened the 1664 at that point. I’ll return to this one day…
 
Hi guys,

Thanks again for all the responses! I'll watch that you tube video and read through them diagrams shortly.

Marconi, thanks for your offer. In short, last night my brother randomly decided he knew where the damage was and so pulled up a load of blocks and exposed the cable (it wasn't where he thought obviously).

Today we agreed to just chop the cable in half where it was exposed and test the two halves (removing half the block paving is a lot easier than all of it right...)

Turns out the problem is at the house end.

I'm totally curious as to how someone with the know how and tools would solve the riddle so have answered your questions below. Out of curiosity, can you see my location? Are you local to Romford/Essex?

1. Yes, it WAS 3 core and 1 complete length (about 25 meters)

2a. Yes, there was only continuity between live and the armour.

2b. Yes, I believe so for 2 reasons, 1, the circuit was working for 2 weeks and no digging occurred in that time and, 2, we connected different pairs up at one end and checked continuity along them at the other (the leads don't reach across the garden so that was the only was to do it).

3. LAP AC/DC Digital Multimeter 600V - https://www.NoLinkingToThis/p/lap-ac-dc-digital-multimeter-600v/161fg that's the multimeter I got but when I tried to measure resistance across the live and armour it just read "ERR". Nothing in the manual about how or why that can happen...

4. The car battery could get directly on top of the wire at the house end and within about 6 foot of the CU at the garage end. I've attached an image of my garden before all the work was carried out. It's basically 2 meters of exposed swa cable at both ends with the garage end running under 5m of concrete slab and then under about 15m of block paving before before rising above ground on the outside wall of where the CU is inside the house.

Thanks again all!

Dan
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20210911-004017__01__01.jpg
    280.7 KB · Views: 21
Well that’s certainly a bit easier than figuring this out…!
I would prefer to to have any significant current going via the fault as we don't know its exact resistance, other than "low".

However, that is something else to check to make sure the resistance of good and faulty conductors is more or less the same, in case there is a chunk of copper blown off it where the fault originally tripped. In my drawing you could also measure a 3rd voltage from conductors 1 & 2 at the sending end - that should be more or less identical to the voltage V1 between 2 & 3 as they should be the same R for #1 (good) and #3 (faulty) under normal circumstances.
 

Reply to Buried SWA cable fault finding in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Similar Threads

Hi All, I'm new to Amtech/Trimble and I've been asked to review a model. I'm looking at circuits that are SWA cables using the armour and an...
Replies
4
Views
596
Afternoon everyone.. During some testing I have found an IR reading of 0.01MΩ between N-E. This is on a length of SWA buried underground from the...
Replies
17
Views
3K
Hi guys, long time lurker first time poster. I have an SWA 3 core armoured cable buried that runs to my back garden. This originally serviced an...
Replies
12
Views
2K
Hi all, I am at odds on whether RCD protection is required on an SWA of 14 metres, clipped direct under flooring direct from CU to an exterior...
Replies
9
Views
850
Hi all, Hope you're keeping well I'm currently wiring a small commercial premises. 3 phas incoming supply, 16sq cables As it is in an urban...
Replies
3
Views
353

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock