1. We've split off Commercial Electrician Talk and Industrial Electrician Talk from the main Electrical Forum. Please take note when you're looking for and posting new threads. :) 

    Checkout the new Electricians Directory which you can add your business details to for free.

    We've also teamed up with an insurance firm to offer you guys some discounted insurance. These guys will customise your insurance to fit your needs perfectly. Enquire using the following pages: VAN - FLEET - PROFESSIONAL INDEMNITY - OTHER TYPES OF INSURANCE.

    Dismiss Notice
  2. Checkout the new BritishForums.co.uk, register for free and enter the competition to win a £25 Amazon Voucher!

    Dismiss Notice

Discuss Out of interest. effect of East/West split on one string? in the Solar PV Forum area at ElectriciansForums.co.uk.

  1. Morgan keith

    Morgan keith Regular EF Member

    I wouldn't do it but a client asked about an east/west split on one string. I couldn't quite describe how bad the effect would be? Would the 8 on the east side(shaded eg.) drag the current down from the 8 on the west (sun shining on)? Or any other answers? Much appreciated
     
  2. Advertisement


    to hide this advert.
  3. SolarCity

    SolarCity Electrician's Arms

    Yes, the panels in the non-sunny area would bring the current down of the sunny area - very inefficient, and depressingly common.
     
  4. BruceB

    BruceB Electrician's Arms

    Location:
    Bath/Bristol
    If the west and east strings have an identical number of panels and the two strings are put in parallel rather than in series, then according to Fronius the effect is not as bad as you might think. There is a paper on the subject on their site albeit I do not have the link to hand.

    With the availability of twin mppt inverters I would not do it though.
     
    1 person likes this.
  5. Earthstore

    Earthstore Regular EF Member

    Tell him to drive his car for a week and see how many MPG's he gets, also ask him if it is slower too.
     
  6. Advertisement


    to hide this advert.
  7. Worcester

    Worcester Trusted Advisor

    Location:
    Worcestershire
  8. Gavin A

    Gavin A Electrician's Arms

    Location:
    Leeds
    Business Name:
    Leeds Solar
    you know why though I assume?

    Because their tripower inverters aren't set up to allow for equal strings on the dual trackers, you can only have 1 string on input B vs 3-4 strings on input A.

    for east west systems I'd spec power one every day of the week, as they allow for equal inputs on each side, and the 30kW inverters are priced better per watt than the SMA anyway, so SMA's argument only holds water if referring to SMA inverters only. It's still a bodge job way of doing things to make up for the inadequacies of their range, just as it was when Fronius were making the same argument IMO.
     
  9. Gavin A

    Gavin A Electrician's Arms

    Location:
    Leeds
    Business Name:
    Leeds Solar
    good to see their analysis of the best sizing of inverters for east west systems aligns with how we've been doing it / trying to do it for the last few years. Some customers won't have it though and insist on the full 3.68kW AC ouput dual tracker instead of the 3kW version that would actually get them a slightly higher output level overall.
     
  10. Worcester

    Worcester Trusted Advisor

    Location:
    Worcestershire
    I realise SMA's reasons, however on some of our larger systems (100kW+) when the roofs are only at 5 - 8 degrees the costs savings and the offer of SMA's PPP output warranty (they'll pay for lost output if an inverter goes down), could outweigh the disadvantages of the single MPPT.

    I've got them (SMA) working on a large project at the moment, we've already sized and designed it using twin tacker STP inverters and optimised sizing so have a good idea what the putput should be, it will be intersting to compare that with SMA's figures:) We've also designed it using Power-One Trio's so the comparisons will make interesting reading, could be a couole of weeks before we know the outcome so will post back here later.
     
Loading...
Similar Threads - interest effect East Forum Date
DNO not interested. Electrical Forum Nov 24, 2016
Domestic Interesting cable system Electrical Forum Nov 4, 2016
Pete's Videos Of interest to anyone? Electrical Forum Oct 15, 2016
Looking for electrician interested in data cabling Looking for Commercial Electricians? Oct 11, 2016
An interesting email I have juist received Electrical Forum Sep 19, 2016