Search the forum,

Discuss Is this within regs? in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

She refused to let me do it because I wasn't qualified

Mam knows best Trev

Your time will come young trev,she said in a very commanding tone, using a North Eastern language that is both strange and puzzling

"but not here not just yet young lad", "Now go and boil that kettle ready for a proper tradesman ,thats a good lad"

The translation into English does not do the sentence justice,but you get the drift I hope

He's having you on anyway , I've never known a Geordie wi a chandelier.
 
It's where they got the sketch from for "Only fools and horses". Guess who trev was :)

Thanks
Ah, its all as clear as broken glass now

His mam wrote the script after he was a naughty boy and spread his wings

Trev,whatever was in that reply you made,thats what I wrote
it sort of got distorted and lost in my translation
 
Obviously ime new round here myself but this is the way I see it.

Most people really learn when they are chucked in the deep end, Much the same as driving you learn once you are in the driving seat on your own.
When I was a apprentice the first time I made off a SWA was a 1.5mm 3 core made off into a metal box and that was the only one I ever made off at college, Every other armored I have ever made off was at work so I became better at it.
I remember struggling my balls off the first few not cutting the armoring properly and attacking it with side cutters (Ahhh the joys of youth eh?)
But I learnt from my mistakes and now think nothing of it, Even chuckle watching my apprentice do the same things I did as my mentor laughed at me.

Engineers learn from doing and from making mistakes, The engineer who has never cocked up has never done anything so fair play to the OP for opening himself up.

He has learnt from his mistake and rectified it, What more could you want?
 
But how can the guy ever get experience if he doesn't try?
I think you've been a bit harsh, ideally he would have got experience from his journeyman but we don't know his background, maybe he had a poor apprenticeship(if he did one that is).

I guess I'm one of the people who's being a bit harsh?

To be perfectly honest if I went to a property and saw him doing that I would have torn a strip off of him, I'm only being gentle on here cos of forum rules.

The way to get experience is not by having a go unsupervised. Should a trainee gas engineer just strike out and have a go unsupervised?
How would you like it if the person you paid to repair the brakes on your car was just spreading his wings and getting some experience on his own?

Don't forget electricity kills people!
 
I guess I'm one of the people who's being a bit harsh?

To be perfectly honest if I went to a property and saw him doing that I would have torn a strip off of him, I'm only being gentle on here cos of forum rules.

The way to get experience is not by having a go unsupervised. Should a trainee gas engineer just strike out and have a go unsupervised?
How would you like it if the person you paid to repair the brakes on your car was just spreading his wings and getting some experience on his own?

Don't forget electricity kills people!

Fair comment!
The point I was making was that he may well be qualified, maybe just lacking in experience. I was let loose on the public as a 4th year apprentice, I didn't know it all, still don't!
 

Attachments

  • GeordieChandelier.jpg
    100.4 KB · Views: 91
There are some good glanding methods out there I feel like I'm behind the times , glanding is pretty easy and yet people seem to make hard work of it and a pigs ear to
va9ehu5u.jpg

It's fine but you have used the wrong colour of tape , other than that it is spot on. The red right next to the fixing hole sets the job off , well done.
 
Is this within the regs? I can't get the thread of the gland through the box to get the banjo inside. I wanted to use the swa but if not will rely on one of the cores.
look..:
if you are not going to gland off and secure an SWA correctly then dont even start the job in the first place....will you..

and posting images of that old tosh in here is just asking for it really....isn`t it..

get it dismantled and done rite...
 
look..:
if you are not going to gland off and secure an SWA correctly then dont even start the job in the first place....will you..

and posting images of that old tosh in here is just asking for it really....isn`t it..

get it dismantled and done rite...


If you bother to read other posts he has already re done it again.

i take it you and alot of members here never asked for advice or never made a mistake out there i wonder how you all learned? sorry i know you all god's gift
 
Personally I think the question asked would be the same as a chippy on a forum asking how to "hang a door" not a specialized one at that lol
 
If you bother to read other posts he has already re done it again.

i take it you and alot of members here never asked for advice or never made a mistake out there i wonder how you all learned? sorry i know you all god's gift

We spent years completing an apprenticeship and having our backsides kicked when we made mistakes. The important thing, however, was that there was someone who knew exactly how to do the job correctly watching over us to step in when we messed up.
Yes, it was done again, but still not to the standard which most of us would expect to see.
 
I agree, that's how we learned and you made sure you didn't mess up again, that's why the apprenticeship system worked far better IMO than all this have a go and check it out on a forum lark FFS how on earth do some of these people dare call themselves sparks lol
 
Good to hear that, it means to me they are being taught correctly and will not be on a forum posing as a sparks asking the basics when the come out of their time.

- - - Updated - - -

they............................
 
If you bother to read other posts he has already re done it again.

i take it you and alot of members here never asked for advice or never made a mistake out there i wonder how you all learned? sorry i know you all god's gift
when i see stuff like that i dont generally bother to read much more of it...
i am sure you can understand this...;)
 
We spent years completing an apprenticeship and having our backsides kicked when we made mistakes. The important thing, however, was that there was someone who knew exactly how to do the job correctly watching over us to step in when we messed up.
Yes, it was done again, but still not to the standard which most of us would expect to see.

Yep, and the basic question is, why would anyone even attempt to complete a task such as this without knowing and understanding the factors and consequences involved. At least he knew there was something wrong and some would have left it as it was, but there's no getting away from the fact that it is trial and error guess work.
 

Reply to Is this within regs? in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Similar Threads

I'm working on a system that has been installed incorrectly. It's a 3ph Hager board with 8 swa cables glanded into the bottom entry panel. The...
Replies
28
Views
3K
I'm looking at a vending hot drinks machine 2.9kW that has a thermostatically controlled hot water tank permanently attached to a water supply...
Replies
2
Views
239
Hi, With respect to the cooker switch only. If I moved it 400mm to the left by extending the T&E from its original position using crimps, then...
Replies
12
Views
2K
Hi all, I have a log cabin in my garden. An electrician ran an armoured cable from my consumer unit to the log cabin and this terminates on the...
Replies
2
Views
707
resitting Saturday my am2 4 sections a3/b/d/e swa and sy failed on protective conductors on both swa i under stand thats the earths i...
Replies
1
Views
1K

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock